The short answer: Before hiring an ecommerce marketing agency, establish how it will assess commercial viability, what it can and cannot influence, how success will be measured, who does the work and what the agreement requires from you. Ask for ownership and access arrangements, a realistic decision process, fees, exit terms and what happens if the numbers do not support scaling. Specific answers matter more than impressive case studies.
9 questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency
- What will you look at before you touch my ads? You want to hear about your margins, product pages and conversion rate, not just targeting.
- What could stop this working that isn’t marketing? A good answer names things like price, margin, site speed or offer. If the answer is “nothing, we’ll make it work”, be careful.
- What do you expect month by month, and why? Ask for a realistic ramp, including the early months, with the assumptions behind it.
- Which numbers will you report? Ask for store revenue and total marketing spend, not only platform ROAS, clicks and reach.
- Who will do the work day to day? Get names and roles, not just the person on the sales call.
- Who owns the ad accounts, pixel and data? You should. Ask for admin access from day one.
- What’s the contract length and exit process? Know the notice period and what you keep if you leave.
- What do you need from me, and how much time will it take? Creative, product info, approvals. Budget your own hours too.
- When would you tell me you’re not the right fit? An agency willing to say no is one more likely to tell you the truth later.
Is a marketing agency worth it for a small business?
It’s worth it when your strategy and site can turn more traffic into profitable sales, and the business can pay for the agency from contribution, not hope. If the product or margin doesn’t work yet, an agency will spend your money finding that out. Check the maths first.
In SSO’s April to August 2026 diagnostic sample, 239 of 259 respondents who answered the question had never worked with an agency, approximately 92%. In that sample, most were looking at outside help for the first time. There’s no shame in asking all nine.
Agency vs freelancer vs doing it yourself
| Option | Suits you when | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Do it yourself | Small budget, time to learn, one channel | Your hours are the cost, and they’re finite |
| Freelancer | One clear task, like ads or email | Someone still has to connect strategy, site and marketing |
| Agency | You need several pieces working together | Make sure they look beyond the one piece they sell |
Signs your marketing agency isn’t delivering
- Reports show clicks and platform ROAS but never store revenue against total spend.
- No one has asked about your margins, product pages or conversion rate.
- Strategy changes every month with no explanation of why the last one didn’t work.
- You don’t have admin access to your own ad accounts.
- The same answer every time: more budget.
How do I read a marketing agency report?
Find three numbers: total store revenue, total marketing spend (including their fee) and new customers. Divide revenue by spend for MER, and spend by new customers for cost per customer. Compare both with your break-even. If the report doesn’t let you do that, ask for it.
Is my Facebook ads manager any good?
Ask them to explain, in plain words, what they changed last month, why, and what happened to store revenue. Good managers can connect every change to a result or a lesson.
Marketing agency lock-in contracts: what to know
A longer agreement is not automatically unreasonable if the scope and investment justify it. Ask about term, notice, exit charges, intellectual property, account access and what deliverables remain yours on departure. Compare the whole commercial arrangement, not just the headline monthly fee.
What founders tell us
-
“Being ripped off by marketers”
founder, about $3K a month -
“Overpaid and they were not making meaningful change on our account”
founder, about $460K a month
Ask prospective agencies to put their assumptions, responsibilities, measurement approach and exit terms in writing before you sign.
FAQ
What does a marketing agency actually do?
It runs some or all of your marketing: ads, email, content or strategy. Ask exactly which.
My agency isn’t getting results. What now?
Ask for store revenue against total spend, and what they’ll change and why. Then decide.
Why do marketing agencies fail small businesses?
Sometimes the problem was never marketing. Check strategy and site before blaming or hiring.
How much should an ecommerce agency cost?
Enough that your contribution can cover it alongside ad spend. Work that out before comparing quotes.
Should I hire an agency or a freelancer?
A freelancer for one task. An agency when several pieces need to work together.
About the author
Mareike NiedermeierMareike Niedermeier is the creator of Survivable Distance, a theory of ecommerce viability. Her work connects the economics a business needs with what it can credibly achieve, then examines the money, skills, time and capacity required to get there. She is the founder of Sales Savvy Online (SSO), an Australian ecommerce agency whose SSO Growth Method applies Survivable Distance in client work.
More about Mareike →Last updated: